Signalling designs

This area is dedicated to our foreign guests of this forum. Contributions can be written in any language.
[Diese Kategorie ist den ausländischen Gästen dieses Forums gewidmet. Beiträge können in beliebiger Sprache verfasst werden.]
Antworten
Chris
Beiträge: 175
Registriert: Donnerstag 24. Mai 2007, 03:26
Wohnort: Cardiff

Signalling designs

Beitrag von Chris »

I have drawn a number of signal graphic concepts, and wondered whether there was interest in adding some signal graphics. By no means is this a proposal to add everything shown below. If there is interest, I'll happily produce the graphics in both zoom levels for all eight directions (and maybe both sides of the track too).

Bild

Top row, from left to right:
<ul>
<li>UK-style 3-aspect signal, on concrete mast, with signal idenfitication plate and sighting board (usually extend around three sides of the signal only. Signal is depicted as "on", with the "caution" and "off" aspects displayed above for reference.
<li>2-aspect signal, as previous. Signal depicted as "on", with "off" aspect displayed for reference.
<li>2-aspect colour-light repeater signal. Depicted "on", with "off" for reference.
<li>London Underground 2-aspect signals, with lower head height for sighting at a driver height of 2-2.5m as opposed to the more conventional 3-4m. Stop signal depicted as "on", also shown are "on" for a repeater signal, and the common "off".
<li>LU combined stop/repeater - arrangement on post separately is generally stop portion above the repeater portion. Signal shown as "stop" with "caution" and "off" for reference.
<li>New-style LED "searchlight" signal - all three colours are displayed through a single lens with LED arrays to show the expected aspect.
</ul>
Middle row:
<ul>
<li>(Not for simulation) LU Central Line ATO signals. White lamp in the middle is "manual stop" - only trains with working automatic controls may pass.
<li>Fiberoptic/LED "banner repeater". The unlit portion indicates the aspect of the next signal. Shown as "next signal on", with "next signal off" hown above. Direction of the diagonal may be wrong. The intention of these is to be "signals without signals". A repeater signal is part of the signalling sequence for the purposes of braking distances, etc., whereas the banner repeaters are not. They are often used at stations where platform furniture might obscure the driver's view of the starting signal.
<li>Position-light shunting signals, shown as "off". Traditional filament signals use a white bulb in the pivot point (so showing red-white in the "on" position), whereas new LED signals will show either red or white at the pivot as appropriate. Yellow signals are used at the exit from sidings to indicate that only one route is controlled (i.e. to the running lines), and that the signal might otherwise be passed if the points are set correctly (i.e. to a loco siding or head-shunt) - the equivalent procedure in BAHN would be to set an auxiliary route code for shunting movements, and use "not valid for these routes" in the signal settings. The original reason for this was not to have drivers knowingly passing red signals at danger.
<li>Disc equivalents of the previous. Yellow band on black indicates that head-shunting etc. is permitted (as previous).
<li>(Not necessarily for simulation) An example of a signal on a side gantry.
<li>(Not for simulation - shown for comparison) 4-aspect signals - traditional and LED varieties. The second array shows yellow only and is placed for enough above the base array to achieve the spacing that you would see at conventional lights.
</ul>

Bottom row:
<ul>
<li>Miniature banner repeater, shown as "next signal on" - "next signal off" shown alongside. These are typically used at canopied stations with curved platforms - a 10-car train might be able to see the starting signal while a 2-car train might not.
<li>(two-images, illustrative purpose only) LBSCR/SR-style semaphores with colour-light repeaters. These were used (IIRC) at fringes between colour-light signalling and semaphore signalling - typically as the last stop signal before entering the CL area.
<li>(three images) A possibility for an overhead gantry design (albeit with poor choice of colour for the structure). Careful observers will note that the central section can be reversed and repeated should more than three signals be needed. Shown are (L-R) a 3-aspect signal at danger, a 3-aspect LED signal at caution, and a 2-aspect signal at danger.
</ul>

Is there any interest in seeing some of the above?

The image in higher resolution
Zuletzt geändert von Chris am Mittwoch 16. Januar 2008, 20:56, insgesamt 1-mal geändert.
Benutzeravatar
micha88
Beiträge: 1987
Registriert: Freitag 18. Februar 2005, 12:50
Wohnort: Marbach am Neckar
Kontaktdaten:

Re: Signalling designs

Beitrag von micha88 »

<table width="90%" cellspacing="1" cellpadding="3" border="0" align="center"><tr> <td><span class="genmed">Zitat:</span></td></tr><tr><td class="quote">I have drawn a number of signal graphic concepts, and wondered whether there was interest in adding some signal graphics. By no means is this a proposal to add everything shown below. If there is interest, I'll happily produce the graphics in both zoom levels for all eight directions (and maybe both sides of the track too).

Top row, from left to right:
<ul>
<li>UK-style 3-aspect signal, on concrete mast, with signal idenfitication plate and sighting board (usually extend around three sides of the signal only. Signal is depicted as "on", with the "caution" and "off" aspects displayed above for reference.
<li>2-aspect signal, as previous. Signal depicted as "on", with "off" aspect displayed for reference.
<li>2-aspect colour-light repeater signal. Depicted "on", with "off" for reference.
<li>London Underground 2-aspect signals, with lower head height for sighting at a driver height of 2-2.5m as opposed to the more conventional 3-4m. Stop signal depicted as "on", also shown are "on" for a repeater signal, and the common "off".
<li>LU combined stop/repeater - arrangement on post separately is generally stop portion above the repeater portion. Signal shown as "stop" with "caution" and "off" for reference.
<li>New-style LED "searchlight" signal - all three colours are displayed through a single lens with LED arrays to show the expected aspect.
</ul>
Middle row:
<ul>
<li>(Not for simulation) LU Central Line ATO signals. White lamp in the middle is "manual stop" - only trains with working automatic controls may pass.
<li>Fiberoptic/LED "banner repeater". The unlit portion indicates the aspect of the next signal. Shown as "next signal on", with "next signal off" hown above. Direction of the diagonal may be wrong. The intention of these is to be "signals without signals". A repeater signal is part of the signalling sequence for the purposes of braking distances, etc., whereas the banner repeaters are not. They are often used at stations where platform furniture might obscure the driver's view of the starting signal.
<li>Position-light shunting signals, shown as "off". Traditional filament signals use a white bulb in the pivot point (so showing red-white in the "on" position), whereas new LED signals will show either red or white at the pivot as appropriate. Yellow signals are used at the exit from sidings to indicate that only one route is controlled (i.e. to the running lines), and that the signal might otherwise be passed if the points are set correctly (i.e. to a loco siding or head-shunt) - the equivalent procedure in BAHN would be to set an auxiliary route code for shunting movements, and use "not valid for these routes" in the signal settings. The original reason for this was not to have drivers knowingly passing red signals at danger.
<li>Disc equivalents of the previous. Yellow band on black indicates that head-shunting etc. is permitted (as previous).
<li>(Not necessarily for simulation) An example of a signal on a side gantry.
<li>(Not for simulation - shown for comparison) 4-aspect signals - traditional and LED varieties. The second array shows yellow only and is placed for enough above the base array to achieve the spacing that you would see at conventional lights.
</ul>

Bottom row:
<ul>
<li>Miniature banner repeater, shown as "next signal on" - "next signal off" shown alongside. These are typically used at canopied stations with curved platforms - a 10-car train might be able to see the starting signal while a 2-car train might not.
<li>(two-images, illustrative purpose only) LBSCR/SR-style semaphores with colour-light repeaters. These were used (IIRC) at fringes between colour-light signalling and semaphore signalling - typically as the last stop signal before entering the CL area.
<li>(three images) A possibility for an overhead gantry design (albeit with poor choice of colour for the structure). Careful observers will note that the central section can be reversed and repeated should more than three signals be needed. Shown are (L-R) a 3-aspect signal at danger, a 3-aspect LED signal at caution, and a 2-aspect signal at danger.
</ul>

Is there any interest in seeing some of the above?</tr></td></table>Please keep in mind how long it would take to scroll through a list of all these additional signalling designs...
Bild
Chris
Beiträge: 175
Registriert: Donnerstag 24. Mai 2007, 03:26
Wohnort: Cardiff

Re: Signalling designs

Beitrag von Chris »

I believe the current list of designs for stop and caution signals is 20 each (x3 for platform designs - not all designs are available on both sides of the track), and the combined signals rather fewer. I figure that in terms of viable designs there are perhaps three viable combined types, five viable stop types, and five viable caution types. Of course, combinatorial problems arise with things such as the gantries...

Perhaps a means of achieving user-defined graphics for track-related elements might be a good idea. For instance, speed limits are shown in the UK using white circles with red outlines (like road signs but bigger).
Antworten